Wednesday, January 28, 2015

A Matter of Mercy: Review and Giveaway

Published in 2014, A Matter of Mercy by writer Lynne Hugo is an emotional story from the start.  Set in Wellfleet, MA, a fishing village, A Matter of Mercy focuses on the traditional way of life in Cape Cod.  The story is told in the third person, mostly from the perspectives of two main characters, Caroline Marcum and Ridley Neal, and to a lesser extent from the point of view of Truro's librarian, Teresa DiPaulo.  At the beginning of the book, Caroline's mother, Eleanor, a potter, is dying of ovarian cancer, and is being cared for by a kind hospice nurse, Elsie.

Caroline, 40, has stayed away from Wellfleet after her DWI car accident in Provincetown over six years ago, when she hit a mother and her child, which killed the four-year-old boy, Alexander.  Caroline has returned home to Wellfleet solely because of her mother's grave illness.  Rid, who's a couple of years younger than Caroline and always calls her CiCi, is also from Wellfleet.  He spent four and a half years in prison for using and selling drugs.  Now Rid is an aquaculturist who works the flats on a 5-acre grant that his father left him, raising and harvesting oysters and quahogs (hard-shell clams).  Rid loves his profession, his dog, Lizzie, and his way of life.  Caroline went to college and became a teacher, but she lost her certificate to teach and also spent time in prison, due to the fatal accident. One evening, Caroline sees Rid working outside and goes out to help him right before a big storm hits.  They end up having a few drinks, and spend the night together, which will alter the course of their lives.  Rid soon learns that a disgruntled homeowner named Pissario has filed a lawsuit against him, Tomas, and Mario (other nearby aquaculturists), and that they may lose their grants.  A bit later in the book, Caroline accidentally encounters Terry, the mother of the child who died in the accident, at the library where she works, and she's forced to revisit her painful past. 

"The sun slid below the horizon degree by degree, a great read neon ball being lowered from an invisible string held by God, fiery and benign.  The bay answered with tongues and darts and minnows of color."
~ A Matter of Mercy, Lynne Hugo

Inspired by a 1996 lawsuit, A Matter of Mercy is a very touching book, that has gotten a lot of wonderful reviews.  It paints a picture of Cape Cod, a complete seascape, with sound, scent, and ocean spray.  While I was reading it, I felt as if I lived on the Cape, and I became immersed in and enamored by a subject that was completely new to me, aquaculture.  The author did extensive research for her book about aquaculture and the aquaculturists, who "live in respectful harmony with the tides and ecosystem of the bay".  In the Author's Note at the beginning of the book, Lynne Hugo mentions an aquaculturist who was especially helpful to her, Barbara Austin.  I was able to "meet" Barbara Austin in a fascinating YouTube video (there's also a character in the book named Barb who's an aquaculturist, mentioned by Rid several times, although this novel is fiction).

A Matter of Mercy is a novel that deserves close attention. The characters and the setting are very well drawn.  The descriptions of the seascape in Cape Cod are magnificent, and the main (and secondary) characters are flawed, realistic, and (mostly) likable.  They make mistakes, they suffer, and they don't communicate freely or honestly.  (After their first chance meeting, Caroline keeps visiting Terry at the library, pretending to be a journalist researching a story; this was painful to read about.)

We have mercy for the characters, and want them to be happy, or at least happier.  The matter of mercy comes up several times in the book, and there are different instances of it throughout.  In this way, the book highlights the need for mercy.  Mercy is compassion or forbearance shown, especially to an offender; it can also mean something for which to be thankful, a blessing (Rid's grant is a blessing to him, from his father).  The last notable instance of mercy was surprising to me, but perfect for this story.

When Lisa from TLC contacted me about this novel, she called it a literary book.  It is a literary book.  I'd definitely like to read other novels by Lynne Hugo.  She has created a story that brings the characters and setting to life, quite vividly.  I was hooked by this story in the first chapter, and my attention remained strong through the very last chapter.  The writing is beautiful and poignant.  I took my time reading A Matter of Mercy, and I truly savored it. 

Thanks to the author and TLC, I'm thrilled to offer my readers a giveaway for a copy of A Matter of Mercy (U.S.A. /Canada).

  • To enter this giveaway, simply leave a comment.
  • For another chance at winning, become a follower of this blog, or indicate that you're already a follower.
  • For an additional chance, post about this contest on your blog, Facebook, Pinterest, or Twitter.
  • If you have read another book by this author, such as Graceland, mention it here for another chance at winning.

Enter by 5 PM PDT on Monday, February 9.  One winner will be selected randomly and announced on Tuesday, February 10.  Good luck to all!

Special thanks to Lisa from TLC for sending me a complimentary copy of this novel.  Please visit the other stops on TLC's book blog tour for A Matter of Mercy


  1. Wonderful review Suko. A Matter of Mercy sounds like a wonderful story. I'm glad you enjoyed it.

  2. I hope I have time to read this story. Sounds wonderful. Maybe it will be a movie?

  3. Superb review Suko! You really seem to have conveyed what feels to be the essence of this book.

    This sounds very good. I am coming to appreciate thoughtful character studies more and more. I think that Complex but likable characters are actually difficult to craft but they add a certain appeal to a book.

  4. Thanks for introducing me to this book.

  5. The descriptive passages about Cape Cod sound wonderful. I've never visited there but I hope to someday. Thanks for a chance to win this book.
    +1 I follow your blog by email: carlscott(at)prodigy(dot)net(dot)mx
    +1 I also pinned an image of the cover on Pinterest:
    I wish I had already read Graceland but I haven't yet. Thanks again.

  6. Your review was captivating. Thanks for this great feature and giveaway. I am an e-mail subscriber. saubleb(at)gmail(dot)com

  7. I really like the review of this novel and it says Read Me.

    I am an email subscriber cenya2 at Hotmail dot com

  8. Great review! This sounds like a really emotional book with a lot of well-drawn characters. Thanks for the giveaway! I'm a follower. diaryofaneccentric at

  9. Such a great review! I am glad to hear that you enjoyed this one so much!

  10. This sounds very good. Thanks for letting us know about it.

  11. Lovely review, good luck to all entering and thanks


  12. I'm so pleased that you enjoyed this book and can recommend it so highly. It sounds like a fantastic read!

    Thanks for being a part of the tour.

  13. What a nice review, so glad you enjoyed the story.

  14. This sounds very intriguing. I haven't read any books by this author, but she definitely sounds like an author to try out!

  15. Such a lovely cover and your review makes this sound like a good one as well. Great review

  16. A Matter of Mercy sounds intriguing, I like the aquaculture aspect of it as well. The setting sounds fantastic and the characters well written.
    Great review as always!

  17. Sounds like a perfect read for follower will tweet@rhondareads

  18. It sounds like there is a lot going on in this novel. Lots of rich characters and a sense of place too. Of course I'm also caught by the idea that one of the characters works in the library...thanks for sharing this one. I've never heard of this author before.


Your comments make this site lively! Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment. I value each one, and will respond to questions.

If you're entering a giveaway, please leave your e-mail address (or a link that leads to it).

Some of the books featured here were given to me free of charge by authors, publishers, and agents. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.


Blog header by Held Design

Powered By Blogger